Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The short verdict (4.5/5): The CLIO Superproof Pen Liner in Kill Brown is the eyeliner I hand to anyone who panics at a flick. The soft brown is forgiving and flattering, the fine tip is genuinely easy to control, and it stays put through a Sydney summer. It loses half a point only because, like most pen liners, it can dry out before you finish the tube, and brown will never punch as hard as a true black.
The CLIO Superproof Pen Liner in 02 Brown is the one liner I keep buying every single time I land in Seoul, and this review is for anyone wondering whether the “Kill Brown” shade really lasts. I picked up two more on my last trip, partly because I had run my old one dry and partly because I wanted to look at it properly for you. Eyeliner is the one bit of makeup I refuse to compromise on, so a smudge-proof claim either earns my trust or it does not — and Sydney humidity has tested plenty of them.

Why I Keep Buying the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner
I am not a person who experiments much with eyeliner. I found a formula that survives my watery eyes years ago, and the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner is the one I quietly repurchase instead of chasing whatever is trending. CLIO is one of Korea’s best-known colour makeup brands, sitting alongside espoir and Peripera on every Olive Young makeup wall, so this is a mainstream staple, not an obscure indie find.
Brown is a deliberate choice, not a compromise. A soft brown liner reads gentler than black, it suits the daytime, no-makeup-makeup look most Korean tutorials chase, and crucially it is far more forgiving when your hand shakes. A wobbly black line looks like a mistake; a wobbly brown line just looks like a soft shadow. That is why I steer beginners toward this colour, and why “Kill Brown” became my default shade.
If you want to see where this liner sits in the wider Korean-makeup world, my round-up of the best Olive Young products puts it in context with everything else worth your suitcase space. This post zooms right in on the one liner I actually trust on my own lids.

The Product: What You Actually Get
The CLIO Superproof Pen Liner is a liquid pen liner, not a gel pot or a pencil. It has a bright red cap over a dark brown barrel, and the tip is a slim, slightly firm felt nib designed for thin lines. The label reads “SUPERPROOF PEN LINER Kill Brown,” and the fine print confirms it is 0.35ml, made in Korea. That is a small amount, which is normal here, because a liner like this is about precision rather than volume.
The headline claim is in the name: superproof. CLIO markets it as smudge-proof, water-resistant long wear, the kind of formula meant to survive sweat, tears, and a humid commute. The 02 Brown shade is a true medium brown, warm rather than ashy, which gives it that soft, lived-in finish instead of a hard graphic line. On the boxes the colour is written as both “02 Brown” and “Kill Brown,” so do not be confused, they are the same thing.
The felt tip is the part I want to flag, because it is the whole experience. It is fine enough to draw a tightline along the lash roots and flexible enough to thicken into a small flick if you press. If you have ever fought a frayed liner brush, you will appreciate how controlled this nib feels, and for anyone still building confidence, a pen like this is far less intimidating than a dip-and-pray liquid pot.

Does Kill Brown Last? My Wear Test
This is the question the whole review hangs on, so let me be straight with you. On my lids the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner genuinely holds up to the smudge-proof claim better than most pens I have tried. I have watery eyes and oily lids, the exact combination that turns cheaper liners into grey smears by lunchtime, and this one stays where I put it. The tightline fades first, but the lash-line itself reads clean for a full work day.
Water resistance is the more impressive part. A splash at the basin or a teary moment does not lift it the way a non-waterproof formula would, and it does not transfer onto my upper lid when my eyes start to crease. It is not tattoo-permanent, and I would not promise it survives a swim, but for daily wear in warm weather it earns the “superproof” name honestly. To take it off I need an oil cleanser or a proper eye-makeup remover, which is the trade-off for staying power.
Here is my honest Korea-versus-Australia note, and it is the reason I stock up at home. CLIO has very limited presence in Australia, so I cannot just wander into a Chemist Warehouse or Priceline and grab this the way I would a local mascara. When you do find Korean pen liners here through specialty K-beauty sites, the price climbs once shipping and markup are added, whereas at Olive Young it is an everyday, affordable buy. If you are flying home through Seoul, this is exactly the kind of small, light thing worth tucking into your bag, and my Olive Young store guide to Seoul maps out which branch to shop.
Pros and Cons
No liner is perfect, and a review that only lists good points is not worth your time. Here is the honest balance after living with the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner across two tubes. On the plus side, the smudge and water resistance is the standout, the soft brown is flattering and beginner-friendly, the fine felt tip gives control that pricier liners often do not, and it is genuinely affordable in Korea.
- Smudge and water resistant — survives watery eyes, sweat, and a humid day without sliding onto the upper lid.
- Flattering, forgiving brown — softer than black, so a shaky line still looks intentional.
- Fine, controllable tip — easy for a tightline and small flicks, friendly for beginners.
- Affordable in Korea — an everyday Olive Young price, not a splurge.
The downsides are the usual pen-liner ones. Like almost every felt-tip liner, it can dry out and go patchy before you have used all the ink, especially if you do not seal the cap firmly. And by its nature brown is less dramatic than black, so if you love a bold, graphic wing this will read too soft for you.
- Can dry out over time — the tip may go scratchy before the tube is empty, as most pen liners do.
- Brown is less dramatic — lovely for everyday, underwhelming if you want high contrast.
CLIO Superproof Pen Liner vs The Alternatives
To put the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner in context, here is how it stacks up against the formats most of you are choosing between. I have used all three styles over the years, and the right pick really comes down to your skill level and how dramatic you want your eyes to look.
| Option | Format | Finish | Wear | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CLIO Superproof Pen Liner (Kill Brown) | Liquid felt pen | Soft warm brown | Smudge and water resistant, all-day | Beginners, everyday soft looks |
| Black liquid pen liner | Liquid felt pen | Bold, graphic black | Long wear (varies by brand) | Dramatic wings, high contrast |
| Gel pencil liner | Twist or sharpen pencil | Soft, smoky, smudgeable | Shorter, sets then stays | Smoky looks, tightlining |
The takeaway is that the CLIO pen wins on control and softness, a black pen wins on drama, and a gel pencil wins for a smudged, smoky eye. None is “better” in the abstract. If you are a beginner who wants a daytime line that does not move, the brown pen is the safest first buy, which is why it is the one I recommend most. To see where it fits among the makeup counters in Seoul, my walk through the Olive Young Gangnam flagship shows the full CLIO and espoir makeup floor where I usually grab it.
Who It Is For and Who Should Skip It
The CLIO Superproof Pen Liner is, before anything else, a beginner’s best friend. If you are nervous about eyeliner, have never managed a clean line, or simply want something soft and natural for work and daytime, this is the one I would put in your hand first. The brown is gentle, the tip is controllable, and the staying power means you can draw it once and forget about it. It is also ideal for anyone with watery or oily eyes, the people most let down by liners that smear by midday, because the water resistance genuinely solves that problem.
Who should skip it? If you want a bold, jet-black, high-drama wing, brown will frustrate you, so reach for a black liner instead. And if you only wear eyeliner a handful of times a year, the dry-out risk means a pen format may waste before you finish it, so a long-lasting pencil could suit you better. Otherwise, for everyday brown liner, this is a very easy yes.
FAQ
Is the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner really smudge-proof?
In my experience, yes, more than most pen liners I have used. On my oily, watery eyes the line stays put through a full work day and resists splashes and tears without sliding onto the upper lid. It is water resistant rather than fully waterproof, so it will not survive a swim, and you will need an oil cleanser or proper eye-makeup remover to take it off cleanly.
What is the difference between 02 Brown and Kill Brown?
Nothing, they are the same shade. The box lists it as both “02 Brown” and “Kill Brown,” which is just CLIO’s naming for their warm medium-brown liner. It is a true brown rather than an ashy or near-black tone, which is what gives it that soft, everyday finish instead of a hard graphic line.
Is brown eyeliner good for beginners?
Brown is the shade I recommend most to beginners. A soft brown line is far more forgiving than black, so a slightly shaky stroke still looks like a gentle shadow rather than a mistake. Paired with the fine, controllable felt tip on this CLIO pen, it makes drawing a clean line much less intimidating than a stark black liquid would.
Does the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner dry out?
Like most felt-tip pen liners, it can dry out before you finish the tube, especially if the cap is not sealed firmly each time. To extend its life, click the cap fully shut and store it horizontally. This is a general pen-liner limitation rather than a fault unique to CLIO, but it is worth knowing before you buy.
Can you buy the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner in Australia?
CLIO has very limited presence in Australian stores, so you will mostly find it through specialty K-beauty websites, where shipping and markup push the price up. At Olive Young in Korea it is an affordable everyday buy, so if you are travelling through Seoul, it is a small, light item well worth picking up there.
My Thoughts
After two tubes, my verdict on the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner in Kill Brown is a confident 4.5 out of 5. It does the one thing I ask of an eyeliner, it stays where I put it on difficult eyes, and it does it in a soft brown that flatters rather than dominates. For an everyday, foolproof line, it is the liner I reach for without thinking, and I will keep repurchasing it.
The half point I hold back is honest, not grudging. It can dry out before the ink runs out, which is the price of the pen format, and brown will never give you a dramatic, head-turning black wing. Neither of those is a flaw so much as a description of what this product is: a gentle, reliable, daytime liner, not a statement one.
If you are buying your first proper eyeliner, or you have given up on liners that smear by noon, let this be the one you try. My own watery eyes have rejected plenty of pretty packaging, and this is one of the few that earned a permanent spot in my makeup bag.
Planning a Seoul Makeup Haul?
🛍️ Where to buy: If you want a liner that survives a humid day without smudging into panda eyes, this is the pen I reach for — the CLIO Superproof Pen Liner on Olive Young Global. (affiliate link)
I curl my lashes first and only then draw the line — same eye routine, just in that order, so the curler never drags across fresh liner. If your lashes tend to drop within the hour, the fillimilli Heated Eyelash Curler is the one tool I would add to the same Olive Young order to hold the curl.